8 Reasons Why Your Garden Carrots Aren’t Sweet

After nearly two months of waiting for my carrots to mature, I was disappointed when I finally had my first bite. They were not juicy and sweet but rather bitter, and some even tasted like soap. I needed to find out where I went wrong to keep it from happening again.

Here are 8 reasons why your garden carrots aren’t sweet:

  1. Growing temperatures are too high
  2. Plant stress
  3. Harvesting too early
  4. Improper storage after harvesting
  5. Exposure to ethylene gas
  6. The carrot variety is naturally unsweet 
  7. Poor handling during harvest and transportation
  8. Aster Yellows disease

Carrots have different tastes for various reasons. Sometimes, there are multiple causes of the problem. I’ll explore why carrots get bitter and offer solutions to the challenges. 

1. Growing Temperatures Are Too High

The sweet taste in carrots is usually due to a perfect balance between terpenoids and the sugars in the root. Terpenoids are naturally occurring metabolites that plants produce. In carrots, terpenes influence the taste and flavor.

Carrots thrive when the temperatures are low, usually around 60-67 °F (15.5-18.3 °C). Terpenoids are produced when carrots start growing. When the temperatures remain constant, the carrots will have enough sugars to balance the terpenoids; these carrots are usually sweet and juicy. 

When carrots grow in hot temperatures (80 °F/26.6 °C and above), they don’t produce enough sugar, so the terpenoid levels will be higher. Additionally, hot summer nights also cause carrots to lose moisture. In the process, the carrots lose sugars. The result will be bitter carrots. 

The best time to plant carrots is during spring, but you need to ensure your timing is right. They need to mature before summer comes along. 

If your area has a short spring season, grow carrot varieties that mature quickly. You can also plant carrots in fall if your area experiences mild winters. However, the carrots will freeze when temperatures fall too low, so you must harvest them before the first frost. 

2. Plant Stress

Stressful growing conditions cause carrots to produce phenolic acid. Plants use this chemical compound to defend against parasites, pathogens, and predators. Phenolic acid also contributes to the carrots’ color. 

When carrots grow in stressful conditions, they react by producing high quantities of phenolic acid, which results in a bitter taste. Such carrots will also have an off-color. For example, some carrots are pale, while others may be discolored. 

If you want your carrots to be sweet, you need to eliminate all sources of stress to the plant. Ensure you remove weeds before they damage the roots. You should also control pests and diseases, water the carrots, and fertilize them. 

This Down To Earth All Natural Fertilizer (available on Amazon.com) is organic and rich in beneficial bacteria. It stimulates root growth and optimum plant development. Besides its positive effect on the plants, this fertilizer encourages soil colonization. This will result in increased crop yields of superior quality. 

3. Harvesting Too Early

Most people harvest carrots early, while others wait for too long. The challenge is sometimes it is difficult to tell carrots are ready, especially if you don’t have a record of when they are likely to mature. 

Since carrots start producing terpenoids when they start germinating, it takes time for them to make enough sugar to balance the terpenoid. When you harvest the carrots early, the terpenoids in the carrots may be too high. The result will be bitter carrots. 

Carrot varieties mature at different times. Some mature after 50 days, others 80 days, while some even take 96 days to mature. Carrots grow faster in warmer months than in cooler temperatures. So, you need to take this into account when harvesting carrots. 

In hindsight, I think I didn’t pay attention to the carrots I planted and when they were due for harvest.  

This video analyzes why home grown carrots are sometimes bitter and what you should do to have sweet, juicy carrots:

How to Tell Carrots Are Ready for Harvest

Carrots are ready for harvest in the following conditions:

Top Height

Carrots are typically ready for harvest when the tops are 1-6 inches (10-15 cm) high. You can get them as baby carrots at this stage, but it is also the ideal time to thin and space them. Give the remaining carrots at least 3 inches (7 cm) spacing so they can grow bigger.

Time Since Thinning

Carrots will generally grow for 3-4 weeks after thinning. With that in mind, ensure you give them plenty of water in the last month of growth. 

Plant Variety

Not surprisingly, different carrot varieties have different top lengths. Find out how tall the top gets for the different carrot varieties at maturity.


A mature carrot has a diameter of about 1 inch (2.5 cm). However, varieties, such as Imperator and Chantenay, are naturally bigger. 

Carrot Varieties & Maturity Period

The chart below breaks down many carrot varieties, along with the length of time before they are classified as baby and full-size carrots.:

Carrot VarietiesBaby CarrotsFull-Size Height
Adana F144 days58 days6-7 inches (15-18 cm)
Bolero56 days66 days6-7 inches (15-18 cm)
Napoli40 days50 days10-12 inches (25.4-30.48 cm)
Canberra80 days96 days18-20 inches (45.72-50.8 cm)
Culinary blends 60 days70 days10-12 inches (25.4-30.48 cm)
Deep Purple F160 days72 days7-8 inches (18-20 cm)
Istanbul60 days75 days9-11 inches (22.86-27.94 cm)
Scarlet Nantes65 days75 days6-8 inches (15-20 cm)
Parano50 days65 days6-7 inches (5-18 cm)
White Satin55 days70 days8 inches (20 cm)
Merida 200 days240 days6-12 inches (15-30 cm)
Carrot varieties and how long they take to mature.

Most carrot varieties will be okay for another 2-3 weeks in the ground after maturity. However, if they stay any longer, they will become woody. It is best to harvest the carrots as soon as they mature.

4. Improper Storage After Harvesting

Poor storage can turn sweet carrots bitter. Before harvesting carrots, you need to know how much you consume and how long you are likely to keep them in the refrigerator. Since carrots can remain in the ground for a few more weeks after maturity, it may be better to harvest what you need. 

However, you shouldn’t leave them in the ground for too long. You’d rather harvest all the carrots and use long-term storage methods, such as canning, or take them to the farmers market. 

Here’s how to keep carrots fresh and crispy:

Remove the Greens

Remove the greens because they will compete with the root for moisture. Unfortunately, the greens always win, so your carrots will not have any moisture left if you refrigerate the carrots with the green top for a long time.

If you don’t have the time to remove the green top immediately, you can leave them on for a few days, but no longer than a week. 

Put Them in Plastic Bags

You should then put the carrots in perforated plastic bags. Doing so will allow the carrots to breathe and, at the same time, retain moisture. Perforated plastic bags will keep carrots fresh for at least four weeks when refrigerated. 

Let It Dry

Next, allow the carrot to dry completely before storage. Washed carrots have a higher moisture level, which increases the likelihood of mold growth and decay of carrots. 

Prepare for Long-Term Storage

When storing carrots for a long time, you should chop, blanch, and freeze the carrots. You can also can them or store them in the vegetable drawer of your refrigerator instead of plastic bags to keep them from decaying. 

5. Exposure to Ethylene Gas

Ethylene gas causes carrots to produce more terpenoids, even after you harvest them. Most fruits naturally release ethylene gas during the ripening process or when there is physical damage to the fruit.

This is why you are sometimes told not to store certain vegetables and fruits next to others because it affects the ripening process. Ethylene gas can change the texture, color, and ripening process, not just of the fruit itself but any vegetable or fruit placed close to the one releasing ethylene gas. 

Apples and pears have high concentrations of ethylene gas, while cherries and blueberries produce very little ethylene gas. Avoid placing your carrots close to apples and other fruits that release high levels of ethylene gas.

Whenever possible, keep carrots away from fruits to ensure their taste is not altered. 

6. The Carrot Variety Is Naturally Unsweet

Some carrot varieties naturally have high concentrations of terpenoid. Purple carrots are not as sweet as most orange varieties.

They have a peppery flavor and are dark purple or reddish-purple with a yellow or orange core. These carrots have at least 20% less sugar. 

Some carrot varieties with a bitter taste include Cosmic Purple, Purple Dragon, and Purple Haze. 

7. Poor Handling During Harvest and Transportation

Carrots that are exposed to mechanical stress, whether you have harvested by hand or by machine, tend to have a bitter taste. Exposing carrots to shaking in a transport simulator causes them to produce more ethylene gas. They also lose some sugars through respiration. 

8. Aster Yellows Disease

Carrots with aster yellows also turn bitter. Aster yellows is caused by phytoplasma, a bacterium transmitted by the aster leafhopper.

Some of the signs that your carrots have aster yellows include:

Alexander Picot

Alexander Picot is the founder of TheGrowingLeaf.com and its lead content writer. He created the website in 2022 as a resource for horticulture lovers and beginners alike, compiling all the gardening tips he discovered over the years. Alex has a passion for caring for plants, turning backyards into feel-good places, and sharing his knowledge with the rest of the world.

Recent Posts