How To Prevent Soil Compaction in Your Garden


Soil compaction is one of the most challenging and common soil issues in a garden. It can create difficulty when planting new seeds, waterlog all of your crops, or make vegetation nearly impossible to grow. If you want to ensure that your garden doesn’t succumb to compaction, you have to be proactive.

Here are 5 ways to prevent soil compaction in your garden:

  1. Add a drainage or irrigation system
  2. Prevent foot traffic on your garden
  3. Add organic matter to your soil
  4. Consider no-till gardening
  5. Don’t work wet soil

Below, I discuss these strategies more in detail and share some tips and product recommendations to help you prevent soil compaction in your garden. But first, what is soil compaction, why is it not good, and what are the signs your soil is compacted.

What is Soil Compaction?

Soil compaction is the increased density of soil and reduced soil porosity owing to stresses applied to the soil. The decrease in the number and size of the pore spaces between the soil particles impedes root growth and function as the pores transport water and air within the soil.

What Causes Soil Compaction?

Soil compaction can be caused by overwatering, loss of organic matter, foot traffic, and various farming practices. It can also occur naturally. Pinning down the exact cause of soil compaction in your garden will help you find a viable solution to soil compaction.

Signs of Soil Compaction

If your garden soil is compacted, there will be a few indicators, including:

  • Standing water on the top layer of the soil due to poor soil drainage
  • Difficulty breaking through the surface of the soil
  • Reduced root penetration in the soil
  • Stunted plants
  • Waterlogged soil

If you’re breaking ground on a new garden area, it’s possible soil compaction already occurred naturally. If this is the case, the soil particles will be packed tightly together, leaving little room for air or organic matter. I explain what this means for your plants in the following section.

Why Is Soil Compaction Bad for Gardens?

Soil compaction is bad for gardens because it can make growing vegetables or flowers difficult. It inhibits the movement of water and nutrients into and through the roots and affects root growth. A healthy root system is essential for plant growth and survival.

Additionally, without many pockets for oxygen and nutrients, the survival of soil organisms is threatened. Like other soil organic matter, soil organisms play a crucial role in maintaining soil fertility, structure, drainage, water-holding capacity, and aeration.

How To Protect Soil From Compaction

The strategies discussed below will help prevent your soil from becoming compacted or even help fix soil that’s already compacted. 

However, some are just quick fixes—for an effective long-term solution, you’ll need to figure out what caused the density of your garden soil to increase in the first place.

1. Add a Drainage or Irrigation System

Overwatering is a common mistake, especially among beginner gardeners, and understandably so. We’re taught plants need water and sunlight to grow— and since we can’t control the sun, we sometimes get a little overzealous when watering them.

That said, overwatering can be a costly mistake. Not only do you waste water and money on water bills, but you also suffocate your plants, which can eventually kill them. In fact, overwatering your plants is much worse than underwatering them and has a much greater chance of causing plant death.

Overwatering your garden can result in waterlogging, where water can’t drain away fast enough. Consequently, there’s excess water in the plant’s root zone. Poorly drained soils are susceptible to becoming waterlogged. And waterlogged soils, in turn, are sensitive to compaction, particularly when you put pressure on them.

Waterlogging can be prevented/controlled by installing a drainage system in your garden and being extra cautious about how often you water your plants and how much water you give them. Whether you’re practicing container gardening or in-ground gardening, you can install a drainage or irrigation system.

How To Ensure Good Drainage in Container Garden

Most plant containers have drainage systems already built into them in the form of a hole at the bottom. However, some flowerpots don’t feature this hole for aesthetic purposes. 

Container gardening calls for drainage because excess water will not have anywhere to go after the plant has absorbed enough water. As a result, the excess water will stagnate at the bottom of the container, putting your plant’s roots at risk of root rot.

When soil becomes saturated with water, you’ll also notice water starts to sit on top since it’s no longer taking in water. Water pooling on the surface is also a sign that your soil is hydrophobic. Another sign you’re overwatering your plant is mold on the soil.

If your plant container has no drainage hole, ensure to drill one. And while you should cover the hole to prevent the soil from washing out, the material you use shouldn’t block excess water from getting out. Plastic mesh and large irregular pebbles are good choices.

How To Ensure Good Drainage In In-Ground Garden

If your in-ground garden tends to get waterlogged, be it from roof runoff water after heavy rain or overwatering on your part, your garden needs a kind of drainage system to remove standing water. Some types of in-ground garden drainage solutions include French drains and trench drains.

Ryan, a Technology and Engineering Teacher with a passion for designing and building, shows you how to install a DIY French drain in this YouTube video:

One of the items you’ll need for this project is this 4 in x 100 ft (10.16 cm x 30.48 m) ADS Perforated Corrugated Drainage Pipe from Amazon. It has holes to allow water to pass in and out of it and is easy to install.

How To Water Your Garden Effectively

If you find that you constantly overwater your plants, installing an irrigation system is the best solution. You can choose between sprinkler systems and drip irrigation. Both irrigation systems allow you to set a watering schedule, which should vary depending on soil type and season.

During Summer, for instance, you should water your plants more often than during Winter. Whereas garden soils with a higher water-holding capacity, such as clay soil, require less-frequent watering.

Just remember to adjust your watering schedule such that the irrigation system only waters on the assigned days each season. Doing this will ensure you don’t overwater your plants, giving them a chance to grow and thrive.

This YouTube video by Texan garden enthusiast Scott Head shows how to install a drip irrigation system:

The irrigation system he used in the video is Optimisland Drip Irrigation Kit, which you can purchase on Amazon. It allows you to water your plants automatically and reduces water use by 70%, which helps you save on water bills.

If you prefer not to install a drainage or irrigation system yourself, you can hire professional gardeners to do it for you.

Pick the Right Spot

If you’re starting a garden, avoid soggy, poorly drained areas in your yard. This will save you the headache of dealing with a waterlogged and consequently compact soil once the planting season begins. Picking a good garden spot might also save you the cost of installing a drainage system.

2. Prevent Foot Traffic on Your Garden

Foot traffic is another common cause of a compacted garden.

If you regularly hike, especially in state parks, you may have noticed how hiking trails tend to be compacted. Continuous foot traffic compacts the surface soil and creates paths, limiting vegetation growth. You may also come across desire paths resulting from trampling by humans and animals. 

Preventing foot traffic—or worse, vehicle traffic—in your garden can help prevent compaction. The following strategies will help you achieve this:

Practice Proper Plant Spacing

If you’ve planted your plants too close together, it affects how they grow and makes gardening difficult. This includes watering, weeding, or pruning. So you may find yourself regularly stepping into the gardening plot to perform these gardening tasks, which is a no-no as you risk compacting your garden soil.

If you can’t easily reach the middle of your gardening plot or get to it, consider spacing your plants further. You can also prevent soil compaction caused by foot traffic by building a designated garden path. Reducing the size of the planted areas in your yard can also work.

Consider Using Garden Beds

Using garden beds—also called garden boxes or planter boxes—can help ensure you and others don’t trample on your garden. You can choose between raised or in-ground garden beds.

Additionally, you can have paths between the beds. How wide or narrow you should make your paths depends on the frequency of usage. High-traffic walkways should be wider.

You can use loose materials like gravel, wood chips, and slate chipping as the surface of your garden paths or solid, durable materials like slabs, decking boards, and natural stone.

Put Up Garden Signs

Putting up a sign discouraging people from walking through your garden can effectively help prevent foot traffic. For instance, you could have a sign that says “Please Don’t Step On The Garden” or “Don’t Walk On Me.”

Signage influences pedestrians and drivers to use alternate routes, i.e., intentionally made paths. You can make a sign yourself or buy one online. 

Build a Garden Fence

If you’re dealing with animal trampling and not human trampling, signage won’t be of any help. Instead, you can put a fence around the perimeter of your garden to keep your dogs, cats, rabbits, or other pets out. Fencing will also help keep people from damaging your plants and beds.

A fence will not protect against birds and squirrels—the former fly and the latter climb. However, these critters are so light that they will barely impact your garden soil’s compaction.

That said, they can still cause damage by eating your vegetables. To keep them out of your garden, you can use a scarecrow or place reflective surfaces on structures surrounding your garden.

In the YouTube video below, Richard Fusinski shows how he protects his vegetable garden from critters using CDs:

Use Lighter Agricultural Equipment

If you’re growing crops on a large scale, using heavy equipment to sow or harvest can cause significant soil compaction. Heavy machinery applies excessive pressure on the soil, causing it to compact.

3. Add Organic Matter to Your Soil

Organic matter is essential to a healthy garden for numerous reasons, including storing and supplying essential nutrients and preventing soil compaction. Organic matter holds soil aggregates together, increasing soil porosity and reducing compaction. 

The two main ways to add organic matter to soil are mulching and composting. 

Mulching

Mulching involves laying organic or inorganic mulches on the top of a soil surface. Organic mulches help retain soil moisture, add nutrients to your garden soil, and protect it and your plant roots from temperature extremes.

Organic mulch also soaks up excess water thereby preventing soil compaction. It comes in many forms including hay, straw, shredded bark, wood shavings, dried leaves, and grass clippings.

As some of these materials are readily available in your garden, it’s a low-budget option of adding organic matter to your soil. However, if you’re an urban gardener or don’t have time to make mulch, you can buy organic mulch.

Here are my top recommendations from Amazon:

  • Urban & Co Thumb Mulch: this ultra-fine mulch made from natural redwood bark is the perfect size for use on indoor or outdoor potted plants. Just lay the mulch on the soil, and you’re good to go.
  • MIGHTY109 Natural Cedar Mulch: this is a dye- and chemical-free mulch made of 100% natural cedar. It’s ideal for application on soil in in-ground gardens and container gardens.
  • USA Pine Straw Mulch: this is a lightweight organic mulch made from pine needles. One box covers 160 sq ft (14.86 sq m) at a depth of 2-3 in (5.08-7.62 cm). Its beautiful natural color helps add curb appeal.

Composting 

Composting involves adding decomposing organic matter into the soil to fertilize the soil and help plants grow. Your compost pile can comprise food scraps, coffee grounds, dead leaves, grass clippings, newspaper, and shredded twigs and branches.

Like mulch, compost can be homemade or store-bought. Some communities also have composting programs that distribute compost locally.

Here are a few products from Amazon I’d recommend, depending on whether you choose to make or buy compost.

Compost Bags and Compost Bins

You can start composting right on your kitchen counter using a compost bin. 

KaryHome Countertop Compost Bin can be mounted on the wall or hung on the doors of kitchen sink base cabinets. It has a 3-gallon (5-liter) capacity and is easy to clean.

To line your compost bin, you can either use recyclable grocery bags or disposable compost bags.

Lucky Family Green Compost Bags are suitable for bins with a capacity of 1.3 – 1.6 gal (5-6 l). One roll contains 50 biodegradable, leak-proof bags.

But what if you prefer outdoor composting?

In this case, I recommend the VIVOSUN Compost Tumbler. It has two chambers, each with a 19-gallon (71.92-liter) capacity. Use it to turn your food waste into nutrient-rich compost within 6-8 weeks.

Ready To Use Organic Compost

If the DIY route is not for you, you can buy compost from your local garden center or online. Charlie’s Compost uses organic ingredients and has an organic certification from the Kentucky Department of Agriculture.

The organic materials used to make the compost include chicken manure, corn stalks, hay, straw, and forest products.

4. Consider No-Till Gardening

Tilling is quickly becoming an outdated agricultural method, and for good reasons. For starters, it contributes to soil compaction by accelerating the decomposition of organic matter. 

As I explained earlier, organic matter binds microaggregates and macroaggregates in your garden soil, keeping it from compacting.

The solution? No-till farming! This technique involves cultivating crops with minimal soil disturbance and leaving crop residue on the soil’s surface.

5. Don’t Work Wet Soil

Working wet soil packs the soil particles tightly together, leaving less room for water and air to penetrate. In other words, it causes soil to become compact.

To determine if your garden soil is dry enough to work, squeeze a small amount in your hand. If it crumbles, you can get to work. But if it forms a muddy ball, give it a few days to dry.

Final Thoughts

Soil compaction alters soil structure, limiting water and air infiltration and causing roots not to grow deep into the soil. This, in turn, affects plant growth and reduces your garden yield.

You can prevent soil compaction in your garden by avoiding practices that apply pressure on the soil surface, such as continuous foot traffic and heavy equipment use. Adding organic matter to your soil also reduces the soil’s susceptibility to soil compaction.

Alexander Picot

Alexander Picot is the principal creator of TheGrowingLeaf.com, a website dedicated to gardening tips. Inspired by his mother’s love of gardening, Alex has a passion for taking care of plants and turning backyards into feel-good places and loves to share his experience with the rest of the world.

Recent Posts